My father-in-law just returned from 10 days of golf in Scotland. He came back exhausted, happy, and full of opinions. Here is what he said the photos do not capture — and what he wishes someone had told him before he went.
September 9, 2026
My father-in-law just got back from Scotland. Ten days total, two of them traveling, eight of them playing golf, including one day where he played 36 holes. He came home exhausted and happy, which is the correct way to come home from a trip like that.
He also came home with strong opinions. Some of them were things I expected. Others surprised me. All of them are worth sharing for anyone who is considering Scotland as a golf destination, because most of what gets written about Scottish golf focuses on the scenery and the history and not on the practical reality of what the trip actually involves.
This was the observation he kept coming back to. The pictures do not do it justice, but not in the way that phrase usually gets used. He did not mean the courses are more photogenic in person. He meant the entire experience is three-dimensional in a way that a photograph cannot capture.
The wind. The texture of the turf underfoot. The way a hole looks completely manageable from the tee and reveals itself as genuinely difficult once you are in the fairway and can see the green complex properly. The sound of the sea. The light in the late evening, which in Scotland during summer stays soft and long past what any American golfer is used to.
He played some of the well-known links courses and said repeatedly that he understood intellectually that they were good, had seen them ranked, had watched them on television and he still was not prepared for what it actually felt like to play them. That gap between expectation and experience is real. It is also a good problem to have.
Scotland is full of old buildings. Many of the nicest places to stay near the famous courses are centuries-old hotels and inns that have been maintained beautifully but were not built with golf travel in mind.
The rooms are often narrow. The staircases are steep. The hallways do not accommodate a golf bag with any grace. He said lugging his gear up to the room each evening was the most consistently annoying part of the trip, not a dealbreaker, but something nobody mentions in the glossy travel content about Scottish golf.
The tradeoff is genuine charm. The towns around the great Scottish courses are some of the most beautiful small towns he has ever visited. Stone buildings, good pubs, local character that has not been built for tourists even though tourists have been showing up for a hundred years. He came back talking about the towns almost as much as the courses.
The accommodation advice for a Scotland trip is this: read the specific reviews carefully, look for properties that mention golf storage or bag rooms, and accept that the nicest-looking options are not always the most practical for a group with multiple sets of clubs.
This one is worth telling in detail because it cost him real stress and could happen to anyone.
He booked Ship Sticks to transport his bag to Scotland rather than flying with it. Good instinct in principle. Shipping clubs internationally removes a significant logistical headache and the service exists precisely for this purpose.
His bag had a small lock on an accessory pouch — not the main zipper, a secondary one. Ship Sticks declined the bag at pickup because of the lock. Standard policy: bags must be fully accessible for inspection. He was not aware this applied to secondary locks and had not been flagged during the booking process.
The result was that his bag got sent back to him two days before departure. He had to fly with it instead, which meant a tight connection became significantly more stressful — checking and re-checking a bag through an international connection with almost no margin for error.
He made it. The clubs made it. But the lesson is clear: if you are using Ship Sticks or any similar service for an international golf trip, do a full audit of every lock on the bag, including accessory pouches, side pockets, and anything that could be construed as secured. Remove them all. Do not assume that a small lock on a minor compartment will be overlooked.
This was the thing he said that I found most interesting, and it is something you do not read about in most Scotland trip write-ups.
At many of the tourist-heavy links courses in Scotland — the ones that attract significant outside play precisely because of their history and reputation — local memberships are structured very differently than they are at comparable American clubs. Members at these clubs often share the course with a substantial volume of visitors. In exchange, the fees are lower and the access is real. The revenue from visitor green fees effectively subsidizes the membership.
He came back thinking this model makes far more sense than what American golf clubs typically offer. A membership that gives you access to a world-class course alongside visitors who are paying $300 a round to be there — and your annual fee reflects that arrangement — is a genuinely different value proposition than the American private club model where the entire financial structure is built around excluding outside play.
Whether that model could work in the US is a longer conversation. But as an observation about why Scottish golf culture feels different from American golf culture, it is a useful one.
He has played Ireland and has plenty of American golf in his history. His summary after this trip:
Scotland and Ireland are both operating at a level of links golf that is simply not replicable in the United States. The terrain, the history, the way the courses have been maintained and evolved over a century or more — it is a different category of experience. The debate between Scotland and Ireland is largely personal preference. Scotland's courses are often more raw and exposed. Ireland tends toward slightly more dramatic scenery in places like Ballybunion or Lahinch. Both are worth doing.
The US has better logistics. Easier to travel to, easier to get bags there, more predictable accommodations, no jet lag. If you are optimizing for ease of planning, a Pinehurst or Pebble Beach trip wins. If you are optimizing for the experience of golf played the way it was originally meant to be played, Scotland and Ireland are in a different tier.
His honest advice: do the Scotland trip. Take ten days. Do not rush it. Skip the Ship Sticks if your bag has any locks anywhere. And do more scotch tasting than he did, because he came home wishing he had made more time for it.
The Starter handles the group logistics whether you are going to Pinehurst or St Andrews. Golf trips, handled.
Ready to plan a golf trip? The Starter handles itinerary, costs, foursomes, and payouts — all in one link.
Golf trip planner →Ready to plan your trip?
Build your itinerary, split costs, and coordinate the whole crew. Free to start.
Start planning →More in Trip Planning